OpenAdLibraryOpenAdLibrary
Ad Transparency & Supply Chain

Who's Liable for Scam Ads? Network vs Advertiser

The advertiser behind a scam ad is almost always the liable party, but tracing who that really is through a resold native supply chain is the part most people get stuck on.

Editorial illustration: Who's Liable for Scam Ads? Network vs Advertiser

This is general information, not legal advice; who is liable depends on the jurisdiction and the facts, so a specific case needs a qualified lawyer. Under US federal law, the advertiser that makes a deceptive claim is the most direct target, but not the only one: the FTC says that in appropriate circumstances it has acted against others who helped create deceptive advertising content, such as ad agencies and operators of affiliate advertising networks. A network that only distributes another company's ad usually has narrower exposure, and in the US it may be able to rely on Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which does not protect a service that is responsible, in whole or in part, for creating or developing the content. Other countries set different rules. In practice, the first hard step is often identifying the real advertiser, who can sit behind one or more reseller or agency accounts.

The basic split: advertiser first, network second#

In the US, Section 5 of the FTC Act and state unfair and deceptive practices laws (LeadClick also involved Connecticut's) generally reach whoever makes a deceptive representation, which is usually the advertiser and can also be an affiliate marketer running its own funnel. Ad agencies can be held responsible too: the FTC says it looks at how far an agency participated in preparing the ad and whether it knew or should have known the claims were false or deceptive. Courts have also applied a "means and instrumentalities" theory to those who put into others' hands the means to mislead the public; in a December 2025 order the FTC described it as recognized where a supplier gives sellers deceptive marketing material, where a product or service is inherently deceptive, or where the supplier knows or has reason to know its customer will use it to violate the FTC Act. In FTC v. LeadClick Media (2d Cir. 2016), the court held an affiliate marketing network directly liable because, knowing of the deception, it participated in it and had authority to control its affiliates' content.

Ad networks usually sit further from the claim. Taboola, Outbrain (now operating as Teads), MGID and similar platforms connect publisher inventory with advertiser demand, and Taboola's and Outbrain's published policies require advertisers' content to comply with them; Outbrain's guidelines say advertisers remain solely responsible for personalised or dynamically generated creative. In the US, Section 230 says a provider of an interactive computer service shall not be treated as the publisher or speaker of information provided by another content provider, but that protection does not cover content the service helped create or develop, which is why LeadClick could not rely on it. How these rules apply to paid ads is fact-specific and varies by jurisdiction. In the EU, the Digital Services Act's liability exemption for hosting services is lost if the provider, once it has actual knowledge of illegal content, does not act expeditiously to remove it, and in the UK the Online Safety Act 2023 sets fraudulent-advertising duties for Category 1 user-to-user services and Category 2A search services.

When a network stops being just a pipe#

Protection can narrow once a network's own conduct becomes part of the deception. The fact patterns below are the kind lawyers and regulators examine; only some have been tested in court, and outcomes depend on the jurisdiction and the evidence:

The network helped create or develop the deceptive content, for example by suggesting claims or edits, as LeadClick did with its affiliates' fake news pages. Network staff reviewed and approved the specific creative or landing page while knowing it was misleading. The network had authority to control the content, knew it was deceptive and let it keep running; in LeadClick the court treated knowledge, authority to control and allowing the deception to proceed as the company's own deceptive practice. In the EU, a hosting provider that has actual knowledge of illegal content and does not act expeditiously loses the Digital Services Act's liability exemption. We found no primary source establishing that a network's own algorithmic targeting, on its own, makes it liable for an advertiser's false claim, or that a payment model such as a revenue share is by itself a basis for liability; both can be part of the evidence about how involved a network was.

None of these are automatic wins against a network. They're the fact patterns that shift a case from "clearly the advertiser's problem" toward "worth investigating the network too." Building that evidence trail takes more than a screenshot of the ad, which is one reason many complaints never get that far.

Who regulators name in an action#

Regulators decide whom to name case by case. FTC cases can name the advertiser, related companies and the individuals behind them; courts hold individuals liable where they knew of the deception and participated in it or had authority to control it. The FTC's endorsement guidance says that when law enforcement becomes necessary, its focus will usually be on advertisers or their ad agencies and public relations firms. Intermediaries have been named where the evidence showed active participation, as the affiliate network in LeadClick was. We have not counted FTC cases, so we can't say how often an ad network is named.

This matters for anyone trying to get a scam ad taken down. Removal and liability are separate questions: the network controls whether the ad keeps serving, so a report to the network is the direct route to removal, while a complaint to a regulator, or a legal claim against the advertiser, addresses accountability.

The reseller problem: liability hides behind identity#

A common obstacle to assigning liability correctly is that native advertising can run through a native ad supply chain with one or more resold layers between the account that buys the ad and the business behind the offer. A scam campaign can run under a reseller's advertiser ID rather than the operator's real business name, so the name you can see in the ad unit may not be the party responsible. Tracing that chain, from the visible creative through the click-trace to the landing page and back to a registered business, makes it more likely that a complaint names the right party. This is exactly the kind of work that how to identify the ad network behind an ad walks through step by step.

The affiliate layer: liability doesn't stop at the advertiser#

Many scam campaigns are not run directly by the brand whose name appears on the landing page, if there is a real brand at all. Some are run by an affiliate marketer or media buyer who bought traffic on a performance basis and built the deceptive funnel themselves. Under the FTC Act, liability follows conduct rather than job title: an affiliate that makes a false claim can be liable for it, and an intermediary that knowingly participates in or controls a deception can be directly liable, as in LeadClick. Brands should not assume an affiliate agreement insulates them either. The FTC's Endorsement Guides say advertisers are subject to liability for misleading or unsubstantiated statements made through endorsements and should guide, monitor and correct their endorsers, and the FTC's endorsement FAQ says delegating part of a promotional program to an outside company doesn't relieve a company of responsibility under the FTC Act. Whether a particular brand is liable for a particular affiliate's ad is fact-specific and needs legal advice.

Contracts push risk downstream, but not liability#

Every layer in a native ad supply chain, network to reseller to affiliate to advertiser, tends to have a contract with the layer above it disclaiming responsibility and requiring indemnification if something goes wrong. Those contracts matter for who ends up paying in the end, but they don't change who a regulator or a plaintiff can name in the first instance. A network's terms of service with an advertiser doesn't bind a consumer who was deceived, and an affiliate agreement's indemnification clause doesn't stop a brand from being investigated, it just gives the brand a mechanism to recover costs from the affiliate afterward, assuming that affiliate still exists and has money by the time judgment comes down. This is why relying purely on contract language as a compliance strategy tends to fail: it manages cost allocation between businesses, not exposure to the regulator or the harmed party.

What to do if a scam ad targets your brand or your users#

If your brand's name, image, or likeness shows up in a scam ad, or your customers are being funneled through a copycat landing page wearing your visual identity, the practical sequence is the same regardless of who turns out to be legally liable, and it overlaps heavily with the standing monitoring covered in brand protection in native advertising:

Capture the full creative, the exact copy, the serving network and the traced landing page before the campaign rotates out. Report the ad through the network's ad-reporting or trust and safety channel; the network controls whether the ad keeps serving, so this is the direct route to removal, whoever turns out to be liable. Report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or to the equivalent regulator in your market. The FTC enters complaints into Consumer Sentinel, a secure investigative database available to law enforcement agencies rather than a public record, and it says it cannot intervene in individual disputes between companies. Talk to a lawyer before deciding whether a legal claim, such as a trademark claim, is worth pursuing. A network report and a regulator complaint cost less, but neither guarantees removal, compensation or enforcement.

How OpenAdLibrary helps#

Evidence of what ran, when, and under which advertiser record helps with every step above. OpenAdLibrary records captured native ads with the dates they were observed, and for native ads it shows the supply chain and the redirect trail to the captured landing page; the free plan includes these for the 20 newest Meta, TikTok and native ads. Searching an advertiser's captured history, and real-advertiser resolution for native ads, require the Founders plan ($29.99/month). A capture is only as complete as what was observed, so treat it as evidence to give your lawyer or the network, not as a full record of a campaign. The index total quoted in the earlier version of this paragraph is withdrawn because no reproducible extract is available.

Frequently asked questions

Can an ad network be sued for a scam ad someone else created?
It depends on the jurisdiction and the facts, and this is not legal advice. In the US, the advertiser or affiliate that made the deceptive claim is the most direct target. A network's exposure grows when it helped create or develop the content, or knew of the deception and had authority to control it but let it run, as with the affiliate network in FTC v. LeadClick Media; Section 230 does not protect content a service helped create or develop. Other jurisdictions, including the EU and the UK, have their own rules for platforms and fraudulent ads.
Is the FTC likely to name an ad network in an enforcement action?
We haven't counted FTC cases, so we can't give a rate. The FTC says that in appropriate circumstances it has acted against others who helped create deceptive advertising content, such as ad agencies and operators of affiliate advertising networks. The intermediary cases we found, such as LeadClick, rested on evidence that the company participated in the deception or had authority to control it and let it continue.
Why is it hard to figure out who actually ran a scam native ad?
Native ads can run through reseller or agency accounts, so the advertiser name or ID visible on a creative may not be the operator's real business. Tracing the supply chain and landing page back to a registered business is usually needed before anyone can say who is responsible.
Does a network's terms of service protect it from all liability?
No. A network's terms govern its relationship with advertisers; they don't bind regulators or deceived consumers, and they don't override liability for the network's own conduct, such as knowingly approving deceptive creative or helping develop it. We found no primary source treating a payment model such as a revenue share, on its own, as a basis for liability; how involved the network was is what matters.
What should I do first if I find a scam ad using my brand?
Capture the creative, copy, network and traced landing page right away, since campaigns rotate. Report the ad to the network and file a complaint with the FTC (ReportFraud.ftc.gov) or your local regulator. Then talk to a lawyer about whether and when legal action makes sense; it helps to have the evidence and a clear idea of who the real party is.
The OpenAdLibrary Team
Written byThe OpenAdLibrary Team
Ad intelligence & native advertising research

We build OpenAdLibrary, the open ad-transparency platform. Every day our systems capture live native ads across Taboola, Outbrain, MGID, Revcontent, Teads, Yahoo and MSN, identify the real advertiser behind each one, and follow the click to its landing page. These guides distill what we see in that data so you can research the market faster.